Reltic Construction Consultants Independent Commercial Advisory
Services
Project types
Who we work with
Projects Scenarios Insights Process About
Contact 020 3576 2851
Reinforcement and pipework laid out before a concrete slab is poured

Insights for homeowners

Do I need an architect, an engineer or both

They are not alternatives. They answer different questions, and most extensions need both answered.

If you are altering the structure of the house, and almost every extension and loft conversion does, you need both. The architect or architectural designer decides what the space is and how it works, prepares the drawings and normally handles the planning application. The structural engineer decides whether it stands up, sizes the beams and foundations and produces the calculations your building control body will want to see. Reltic does neither. What we can do is help you choose them, agree what each is covering and keep their work in step with the builder, which is part of home project management for private clients.

The confusion is understandable, because on a small job one appointment can feel like enough. It rarely is. A beautiful drawing with no calculations behind it will not get you through building control, and a set of calculations with no considered layout will give you a house you do not want to live in.

What the architect is for

The architect works out what you are building: the layout, the light, the relation between the new space and the house you already have, the materials and the way it looks from the street and the garden. They produce the drawing set that everything else depends on, and they are usually the ones who deal with the planning application, including the design and access material where it is needed.

Architect is a protected title in the United Kingdom and architects are registered, which is worth knowing when you are comparing people who describe themselves differently. An architectural technologist or designer may be entirely capable of the work on a domestic extension, but you should know which you are appointing and what they are and are not taking responsibility for.

What the architect does not do is price the building. A design can be excellent and unaffordable at the same time, which is why the budget wants testing in parallel rather than afterwards. We cover that in whether your extension budget is realistic.

What the structural engineer is for

The engineer answers a narrower and harder question: does this stand up, and what size does each element have to be. On a typical rear extension that means the beam over the new opening, the padstones and columns that carry it, the foundation design, and the effect of removing part of a load bearing wall. On a loft conversion it means the new floor structure and how the roof is supported once purlins are removed.

The output is drawings and calculations. Those calculations are what your building control body checks against the building regulations, so they are not optional paperwork, they are the evidence that the structural design complies. The engineer carries the professional responsibility for them.

Engineers are also the right people to ask about the existing building. Signs of movement, an old extension built on inadequate foundations, a chimney that is being altered, a neighbour’s wall that the works come close to. Those questions are cheaper answered before the design is fixed.

Where the two overlap, and where things get missed

The gaps between appointments are where cost and delay live. Drainage is a common one: the architect shows a line, the engineer assumes somebody has checked the levels and the connection, and the builder discovers the fall does not work after the slab is down. Thermal and fire requirements are another, sitting in the architect’s specification but interacting with the structural build up.

Who is responsible for the building regulations submission is the single most common unagreed item. It can sit with the designer, with the engineer for their part, or with you, and it has to be settled in writing rather than assumed, because the duty to notify rests with the owner or the person carrying out the work. We set the responsibilities out in building control on a home extension, and who does what.

Our job on a project is to make those boundaries explicit before anybody relies on them, so that no item is left with two people each assuming the other has it.

Who appoints them, and what that means

You appoint the architect and the engineer directly, in accordance with what the project needs, and you pay them directly. That is deliberate. It keeps their duty to you, keeps their fees visible as separate lines in your budget, and avoids a structure where the people designing the work are paid by the people building it.

Design and structural calculations remain the responsibility of the respective specialists throughout. Reltic does not design, does not carry design liability and is not the Principal Designer or the Principal Contractor under the CDM regulations. If you already have an architect or an engineer in place, we work with your existing team rather than trying to replace people who are doing a good job.

What we add is the commercial and coordination side: scopes that do not overlap or leave gaps, information arriving when the builder needs it, and a single programme that the design, the consents and the construction all sit on. That is the subject of coordinating your architect, engineer and builder.

What this means for you

Assume you need both unless somebody competent has told you in writing that the structure is untouched. Appoint the designer for what the space is and the engineer for whether it stands up, agree in writing who is making the building regulations submission, and have the budget tested against the design rather than after it.

If choosing between consultants is the part you do not feel equipped for, that is a reasonable thing to ask for help with. We can put forward people we have worked with, tell you plainly what we think, and leave the decision and the appointment with you.

Not sure who you need to appoint, or in what order?

Tell us what the scheme involves. We will set out which disciplines it needs, what each should cover and where the gaps usually appear.

Related