Reltic Construction Consultants Independent Commercial Advisory
Services
Project types
Who we work with
Projects Scenarios Insights Process About
Contact 020 3576 2851
Rows of London houses seen from the air

Insights for homeowners

Is my house extension budget realistic

The figure in your head came from somewhere. Whether it survives contact with a builder depends on what it was built from.

You cannot tell whether a budget is realistic until you know three things: what exactly it is meant to cover, what condition the existing house is in, and what specification you are assuming. Until those are written down, a budget is not a budget, it is a hope with a number attached. The quickest way to find out is to have the scheme priced from measurement against your own brief, which is the work that an independent quantity surveyor on your side does before any design fee is committed.

Most budgets that fail do so for one of two reasons. Either they were set with a rate per square metre taken from somewhere else, or they covered the building work and quietly excluded everything around it. Both produce a figure that feels researched and is not.

Why a rate per square metre misleads on a house

A rate per square metre is an average of other people’s projects. It carries their ground conditions, their access, their specification and their structural solution, none of which are yours. On a new build of repeated units an average can be a reasonable starting point. On an extension or a loft conversion, where you are cutting into an existing building, the averages hide exactly the things that decide the cost.

Two extensions of identical floor area can differ substantially because one needs underpinning and the other does not, because one has a steel frame holding up the back of the house and the other has a simple lintel, because one has a side return a wheelbarrow cannot get down, or because one has a glazed roof and the other has felt. Area does not know any of that.

The same trap sits in the opposite direction. A low rate can be perfectly achievable with a different specification than the one in your head, so the budget is not wrong in the abstract. It is wrong for the house you are imagining.

What you can check yourself before anybody prices it

Write down the specification you are actually assuming, room by room, at the level of what you would notice: floor finishes, kitchen, sanitaryware, glazing, heating, whether the rest of the house gets redecorated where the works meet it. Then ask yourself whether the figure in your head was ever meant to include those.

Next, list what you know about the existing building. Age, whether there is a basement or cellar, whether there are signs of movement, whether the drains run under the footprint, whether the roof is coming to the end of its life, whether there is a party wall involved. Each of those is a cost or a risk, and on an older London house most of them are live.

Finally, separate the building contract from everything else. Fees, statutory charges, surveys, things you buy yourself and a contingency sit outside the builder’s price, and they are not a rounding error. That list is in the costs that sit outside a builder’s quote.

What a benchmark estimate actually gives you

A benchmark estimate prices your scheme, on your house, to a stated specification, with the assumptions and the exclusions written on the face of it. It is built from measurement rather than from an average, which means that when something in it looks high you can see which item is driving it and decide what to do.

The output is a number with a range around it and a list of the things that would move it. That is what makes it usable. You can take it to a design conversation and say that the scheme has to work inside this figure, which is a far stronger position than discovering in month six that it never could.

It also tells you where to spend design effort. If the structure is what is driving the cost, the money goes on getting the structural solution right early rather than on another layout option.

What the documents need to say

For an estimate to be worth anything it has to be clear about three things: what is included, what is excluded and what has been assumed where information does not exist yet. An estimate without exclusions is not optimistic, it is incomplete, and it will be the document everybody argues about later.

Hypothetical example, for illustration only. Suppose an estimate comes back at £240,000 for the building work with a stated exclusion for the kitchen and for any underpinning, and you had £250,000 in mind covering everything. The estimate has not told you that you can afford the scheme. It has told you that you cannot, and it has told you early enough to change the scheme rather than the funding. Those figures are illustrative and not a quotation.

That is the real function of testing a budget. Not reassurance, but an early and specific answer, with enough detail that you can act on it.

What this means for you

Treat the first estimate as a tool rather than a verdict. If it comes back above your figure, the useful response is to ask which items are driving it and what the alternatives cost, because that conversation is where a scheme gets reshaped into something affordable.

If your budget came from a neighbour, an agent’s guess or a figure in a magazine, treat it as a starting hypothesis rather than a plan. Testing it costs a fraction of a design fee and it is the one piece of work that can save you from paying for drawings of something you were never going to build.

A view on the budget is a defined piece of work with a fixed fee and a written report, and you are free to stop there. If you want the same discipline carried through tendering, the contract and the payments, that is home project management in London and the whole way through to handover.

Want the budget tested before you commission drawings?

We price your scheme from measurement against your brief and tell you the gap in money, with the assumptions written down.

Related