Nothing gets built on your job until the change has been described, priced, checked and agreed in writing, including its effect on the completion date. That one rule removes most of the money arguments on a domestic project, and it is the rule that running the money through the build exists to enforce. It is also unpopular at the moment it bites, because the builder is standing in front of you with the wall open and a decision is needed today.
The reason to hold the line is arithmetic rather than principle. A change priced in advance is a negotiation between two people who can both still walk away from that particular item. A change priced afterwards is a negotiation about work that already exists, and the only available answers are pay it or fall out.
Describe the change before pricing it
Write one short paragraph saying what is changing, where, and why. Two sentences is usually enough, and it has to be specific enough that somebody who was not there could tell whether the work had been done. Attach a marked up drawing or a photograph if it helps, which on site it usually does.
Then say what it replaces. Most changes are not purely additional: they substitute something that was in the original scope. Recording the omission at the same time as the addition is what keeps the account honest, and it is the item most often left out.
Note whether the change affects anything already agreed with the designer, the engineer or building control. A change to a structural element or to the drainage may need the engineer to confirm it and the building control body to see it, and that affects the programme as much as the price.
Ask for the build up, not a lump sum
A figure on its own cannot be checked. Ask for quantities, rates and the basis of each: labour, materials, plant, and any addition for overheads and profit. Where the work is similar to something already priced, the original rates are the natural starting point, and a departure from them needs a reason you can hear.
Day rates have their place for genuinely undefinable work, such as investigating something behind a wall before anybody knows what is there. They are a poor basis for defined work, because they pay for time rather than for output. If day rates are proposed, agree the rate, the number of people and a cap, and agree that the work will be recorded daily and signed.
The same logic applies in reverse when work is omitted. An omission priced at the builder’s convenience rather than at the original rates is not a saving. The way variations are valued on larger jobs is in valuing a variation.
Agree the effect on time at the same moment
A change that adds two weeks to the programme costs more than its own price, because the builder is on site for longer and because your own arrangements move. If the time effect is not agreed with the price, it will be asserted later, usually when the completion date has already passed.
So the form has three boxes, not one: the scope, the money and the time. Any of them left blank is an argument postponed. Where the answer is that there is no effect on the completion date, write that down too, because silence is not the same as nil.
If a change is urgent and genuinely cannot wait for a full price, agree a cap and the basis in writing on the day, then price it properly within the week. A capped instruction is a compromise, an open one is not.
Keep one running schedule
Hold a single list of changes: number, date, description, agreed value, time effect, and whether it is agreed or still open. Update it every week and reconcile it to the contract sum, so you always know what the job is now expected to cost rather than what it was expected to cost at the start.
That schedule is also the backbone of the final account. If it has been kept, closing the job is an afternoon of checking rather than a month of reconstruction, which is the difference described in what to check before the final payment.
Send the updated figure to yourself in an email each month if nobody else is doing it. The value is in the habit rather than in the format.
What this means for you
The objection you will hear is that this slows the job down. In practice it does the opposite, because the alternative is a stack of unpriced items that have to be unpicked at the end, usually while the builder is waiting to be paid and you are waiting to move back in.
If a builder will not price changes in advance at all, that is useful information before you sign rather than after. It tells you how the final account is going to be assembled.
One rule, applied consistently: nothing is built until the scope, the price and the time effect are agreed in writing. It will feel pedantic in month one and it is the reason the account still makes sense in month six.
Where we are administering the contract, changes are priced and agreed before the work is done and the running total is reported to you every week, so the final figure is arrived at rather than discovered. If something has already been built without a price, that can still be tested, and we deal with that in what to check when a builder charges for extra work.
This article is general information about running a building project, not legal advice on your contract.
Changes arriving faster than you can price them?
We price and agree every change before the work is done, and report the running total against the contract sum each week.