Reltic Construction Consultants Independent Commercial Advisory
Services
Project types
Who we work with
Projects Scenarios Insights Process About
Contact 020 3576 2851
A variation account being checked against the original scope of works

Insights for homeowners

My builder is charging for extra work, what should I check

Some extras are genuine and some are work that was always included. The difference is decided by documents, not by tone.

Test every charge against four questions. Was this work already inside the scope you agreed. If not, who instructed it and when. Was the price agreed before the work was done. And is the amount a fair valuation of what was actually carried out. A charge that fails the first question is not an extra at all, and that is the most common outcome when somebody independent checks the account line by line rather than reading the total.

Approach it as a document exercise rather than an argument. The question is not whether the builder is being reasonable, it is what the contract and the drawings said and what the records show. That keeps the conversation civil and it is also the only way to reach an answer you can rely on.

Question one: was it already in the scope

Go back to the documents the price was based on: the drawings with their revision numbers, the specification, and any schedule of work that formed part of the deal. If the item appears there, it is included, whatever has been said since. Work that was always necessary to achieve the specified result is generally part of the job even if it was not spelled out item by item.

This is where a cheap initial price shows its real cost. A builder who priced the drawings narrowly will find genuine gaps, because the gaps were the reason the figure was attractive. That pattern is worth understanding before you choose, and it is why we wrote how to spot missing work in a builder’s quote.

Keep the distinction between three different things clear in your own mind: work that was always in the scope, a genuine change that you asked for, and putting right something that was built incorrectly. Only the middle one is an extra.

Question two: who instructed it, and when

A change needs an instruction from somebody with authority to give one. On a private job that is usually you or whoever the contract names, and if the contract does not say, that is a gap worth closing now rather than later. A conversation on site is how most domestic changes arise and it is also why most of them are disputed.

Look for the trail. An email, a note in a meeting record, a message confirming a choice. If the only evidence is a recollection, both parties will remember it differently in good faith. The existing article on verbal instructions on site sets out how that unravels.

If work was done without any instruction at all, say so plainly and early. The longer a charge sits unchallenged on an account, the more it looks accepted.

Question three: was the price agreed before the work

The strongest position is the one taken in advance. If the price was agreed before the work was built, the only remaining question is whether the work was done. If it was priced afterwards, you are negotiating with the work already standing there, which is a much weaker place to be and the reason we insist on pricing changes first. The method is in agreeing the price of a change before work starts.

Where the price was not agreed in advance, you are entitled to look at how it has been built up. Ask for the quantities, the rates and the basis. Rates from the original price for similar work are the natural starting point, and a new rate needs a reason.

Watch for an extra priced on day rates when the work was measurable. Day rates reward time spent rather than work done, and they should be the exception for defined work rather than the default.

Question four: is the valuation right

Check the arithmetic and check the quantities against what is actually there. Measure the area, count the units, look at whether the item claimed is the item built. On domestic accounts, simple duplication is common: an item appears in the original price and again as an extra, or a change that replaced original work is charged in full without the omitted work being credited.

That credit is the point people forget. If a change means something in the original scope is no longer being done, the value of the omission comes off. A fair account shows both sides.

Hypothetical example, to illustrate the structure rather than any real project. Suppose a change to the rear opening is charged at £4,800. If the original price included £1,900 of work that is now not being done, the net change is £2,900, not £4,800. The figures are illustrative only.

What this means for you

Keep the tone factual throughout. The question is what the documents say, not whether anybody is behaving badly, and a charge withdrawn after a calm conversation about the original scope is a far better outcome than a dispute that sours the rest of the job.

Ask for every extra in writing, with the instruction it relies on and a build up of the figure. Check it against the original documents before you respond on price. Deal with each one as it arises rather than letting them accumulate into a single disputed total at the end, which is how a job that was going well turns into a final account argument.

If the account has already grown and you cannot tell what is genuine, a review of the documents will usually sort the claims into the three categories quickly. We will tell you what, if anything, is actually due, and what to put in writing.

This article is general information about running a building project, not legal advice on your contract.

Extras arriving that you cannot test?

Send the contract documents and the charges. We will tell you what was already in the scope and what, if anything, is genuinely due.

Related