Work from a list of your own rather than reading the quote on its own terms. Write down everything the finished job has to include, then go through the quote marking each item present, absent or ambiguous. Anything you cannot find is a question, and the answers to those questions are worth more than the total at the bottom. This is the first thing help comparing builders’ quotes does, because a price can only be compared once you know what it covers.
The reason gaps are so common is rarely dishonesty. A builder prices what is drawn and specified, and on a domestic job the drawings are often silent on exactly the items that cost money. Where the document says nothing, the price says nothing, and the work still has to happen.
The items most often absent
Making good where the new work meets the old: decoration, flooring, skirtings, the ceiling line in the room next door. Drainage alterations and the connection itself. Electrical work beyond the obvious, including moving the consumer unit if the new circuits demand it. Heating, including whether the existing boiler can serve the extended house and whether radiators are being moved.
Then the ones that look like somebody else’s problem. Scaffolding, skips and waste removal, temporary protection of the parts of the house you are still living in, temporary weatherproofing, cleaning at the end. Builders differ on which of these they consider part of the price, and the differences are large enough to change the ranking of two quotes.
Finally, the finishes. Kitchens, sanitaryware, tiles, floor coverings, wardrobes, light fittings and the garden are commonly either excluded or carried as an allowance. We go through the whole set of costs around the contract in what to allow for beyond the builder’s quote.
Read the words, not the figure
The exclusions in a domestic quote usually live in the covering email and in short phrases inside the document. Subject to, excluding, allowance for, by others, assumed, where required, to be confirmed, provisional. Each of those is a place where the price is not a price.
Allowance is the one to watch hardest. An allowance for a kitchen is a placeholder that will be adjusted to whatever you actually buy, which means the total you are comparing contains a number nobody intends to stand by. Two quotes with very different allowances are not two different prices for the same job, they are two different guesses about your taste.
Provisional items behave the same way. They signal work that is expected but not yet defined, and they will be remeasured and repriced when the detail exists. Knowing which items are provisional tells you where the total is likely to move.
Put every price on one basis
The method that works is to write a single schedule of the work, in your own order, and ask every builder to price against it. Then the comparison is item by item rather than total against total, and a gap shows up as a blank line rather than as a lower figure.
If the quotes are already in and you would rather not go back out to the market, the same thing can be done in reverse: build the schedule from the most complete quote and map the others onto it, asking each builder to confirm or price the items they did not mention. That conversation is also informative in itself, because how a builder responds to being asked for detail tells you something about how they will behave during the job.
This is the work behind why two prices for the same drawings can sit thousands apart, which we deal with in how to read a builder’s quote.
What documents you need for this to work
A drawing set with numbers and revisions, so that everybody is pricing the same design. A written specification covering the finishes and the fittings, at the level of what you would notice in the finished room. A schedule of the work, which is the document most private projects never produce and the one that makes comparison possible.
Where information does not exist yet, say so on the face of the schedule and state the assumption, rather than leaving the builder to assume privately. An assumption written down is a question you can answer later. An assumption left unwritten is an extra.
Once that set exists it is also the basis of the contract, so the work is not wasted. What to settle in the contract itself is in what to agree before the builder starts.
What this means for you
Expect the exercise to produce questions rather than certainty, and treat that as progress. A quote with twelve written answers attached to it is a far safer basis for a contract than a quote that looked tidy because nobody interrogated it.
It is also worth asking each builder what they would add if they were pricing the job properly rather than competitively. The answers tell you which of them has actually thought about your house, and that is usually the one whose price holds.
Do not try to find the gaps by reading harder. Build your own list, mark the quote against it, and treat every unanswered item as a question to be put in writing before you sign anything. The exercise takes an evening and it changes what you are looking at.
If you would rather have it done properly, a written view on the prices you already hold is a defined piece of work with a fixed fee. You get a report setting out what each price covers, what is missing and where the extras are likely to come from, and you are free to use it and stop there.
Holding quotes you cannot compare?
Send them with the drawings and the specification. We will put every price on one basis, item by item, and show you what each builder has left out.