Walk the job room by room, in daylight, with the drawings and the specification in your hand, and write down every item with its location and what is wrong with it. Separate the three categories as you go: work that is defective, work that is unfinished, and work that was never in the scope. Only the first two belong on the list. Doing this properly, and doing it before the final payment rather than after, is one of the points at which having somebody on your side is worth the most, because leverage disappears the moment the money has gone.
One caution first. Snagging is a finishing exercise, not a substitute for inspection during the works. The things that matter most, the structure, the insulation, the drainage, the waterproofing, are all covered up long before handover. If nobody checked them at the time, a snagging list at the end cannot find them.
Go room by room with the documents in your hand
Take the drawings, the specification and your schedule of changes. Start at one end and work through consistently: floor, walls, ceiling, joinery, glazing, services, then fittings. Record each item with the room, the location within the room and a short description of what is wrong. Photograph everything, with something in shot to give scale where it matters.
Check against the specification rather than against your memory of the conversation. If the specification said one thing and something else has been installed, that is a substitution to be dealt with on the account, not a snag. If it is what was specified and you no longer like it, that is a change and it is yours.
Check the things that are easy to miss because they are not at eye level: the tops of doors, the backs of cupboards, loft access, external ground levels and the drainage gullies, the parts of the garden the works used as a compound, and the rooms you were living in while the work happened.
Test what can be tested
Open and close every window and door, including the locks and the restrictors. Run every tap, fill and drain every basin, bath and shower, and watch for leaks under the units afterwards. Flush the toilets. Run the heating and check every radiator heats across its whole surface. Switch every light and socket, and check the extract fans actually move air.
Look along surfaces rather than at them. Flat planes such as plasterboard, tiling and flooring show defects in grazing light that are invisible head on. Do the same for paintwork and for the line of the new ceiling where it meets the old.
Be realistic about tolerance. Building work is not cabinetmaking, and some variation is normal rather than defective. The question is whether the work meets the standard that was specified and whether it is reasonable for the trade involved, not whether it is perfect.
What the list should look like
A table, numbered, with columns for the room, the item, what is wrong, who is responsible, the date it was raised, the date it was agreed as fixed, and a reference to the photograph. Numbered items matter, because a list without numbers becomes impossible to track once half of it is done.
Issue it in writing to the builder and ask for a date against each item rather than a general assurance. Then re-inspect and sign items off individually. An item is closed when you have seen it, not when you have been told about it.
Keep the list open rather than reissuing a new version each time, so there is one document with a history. If a new item appears during the re-inspection, add it to the bottom with its own number.
How the list relates to completion and to the money
Practical completion and perfection are not the same thing. A job can reach completion with a list of minor items outstanding, and the defects period that follows exists precisely so that things which appear later can be put right. What completion should not mean is that substantial work is still missing.
The money mechanism that supports all this is the retention: a percentage held back, part released at completion and part after the defects period has run. That is the reason to have agreed a retention in the contract at the start, and the reason not to release the final part simply because the date has arrived. The way that mechanism works is in defects, retention and the last five per cent.
Items that appear months later are a different category again, and they are what the defects period and any applicable guarantees are for. Record them the same way and raise them in writing as they arise.
What this means for you
Be proportionate as well as thorough. A list of two hundred trivial items invites the builder to treat the whole document as unreasonable, while a list that separates genuine defects from minor marks tends to get worked through. The purpose is a finished house, not a scorecard, and a list the builder is willing to engage with gets more items put right than one that is argued about from the first page.
Compile the list yourself before anybody talks about a final payment, in daylight, with the documents, numbered and photographed. Separate defective work from unfinished work from changes you want. Issue it in writing, get dates against items, and close items only when you have seen them.
Then hold the retention until the list is genuinely closed, and keep the final part until the defects period has run. What else to have in place before that last payment is in what to check before the final payment to your builder.
Approaching handover and unsure what to look for?
We draw up the list of defects, issue it, re-inspect against it and hold the retention until the items are genuinely closed.